🔗 Share this article

The federal high court on Friday permitted the Trump administration to remove TPS benefits from more than 300,000 Venezuelan migrants.

Court's Urgent Ruling

The judges delivered an interim ruling, which will remain in effect throughout the court case continue, putting on hold a earlier judicial finding that had halted the administration from terminating protected immigration status for the Venezuelans.

The dissenting members filed dissents.

Additional TPS Terminations

The Republican administration has moved to withdraw various protections that permit migrants to live in America and hold jobs lawfully, including terminating protected status for a aggregate 600,000 Venezuelans and half a million Haitian nationals who were given legal status under the Biden administration.

TPS is awarded for periods of 18 months.

Earlier Judicial Intervention

In the spring, the high court set aside a preliminary order that impacted another 350,000 Venezuelans whose protections ended last spring.

The justices offered no clarification at the time, which is common in emergency appeals.

“The same result that we decided in May is fitting here,” the court declared in an unsigned order.

Impact on Migrants

Some migrants have become unemployed and homes while others have been detained and removed after the judges stepped in the initial instance, lawyers for the migrants told the court.

Disagreement from Justices

“I regard today’s decision as yet another improper use of our interim proceedings,” a dissenting judge stated. “Because, respectfully, I cannot abide our ongoing, unwarranted and detrimental meddling with ongoing litigation while lives hang in the balance, I disagree.”

History of Protected Status

Congress established TPS in 1990 to stop expulsions to countries undergoing natural disasters, civil strife or additional hazardous situations.

The classification can be awarded by the head of DHS.

Earlier Judicial Determination

The trial court judge found that the federal department acted “with unusual rapidity and in an unusual fashion … for the predetermined goal of accelerating the revocation of Venezuela’s TPS benefits.”

In earlier rejecting the government's interim application, a different jurist represented a consensus judicial group that the lower court had determined that DHS made its “conclusions initially and sought legal grounds for those decisions afterward”.

Courtroom Debate

The government's lead attorney had asserted in the latest legal submission that the court's spring ruling should also apply to the present litigation.

“This case is well-known to the court and involves the growing trend and unacceptable occurrence of lower courts disregarding this court’s decisions on the emergency docket,” the counsel stated.

The consequence, he said, is that the “latest ruling, just like the earlier ruling, stopped the nullification and conclusion of TPS concerning over 300,000 aliens based on unfounded arguments”.